Alfy's Pizza

Pretty good. Peaceful, comfortable, and quiet enough to carry on a conversation without yelling across the table. I was pleased. Also the restaurant was clean. We had the Royal, very tasty.

Not too busy on a Saturday afternoon. Large salad bar with lots of choices. Pizza was very good, fresh ingredients, good flavors. Interior and atmosphere are typical American style pizza joint, open seating, Small tables. Good view of the harbor. Service was fast and friendly.

Fabulous pizza and salad bar. Friendly staff. Great view!

Best Gluten free pizza ever!! Seriously, try the pesto sauce with grilled chicken, garlic and Parmesan. So delicious!

Affordable, nothing special pizza, all you can eat salad bar for only $8! Half price pizza daily between 11-1! Full bar and beautiful views!

Great pizza and service! Love the bay windows, but it gets a bit bright and there are no shades to bring down. Never wait for my food long. Not many options for pizza on the menu as I expected, however, the options available are delicious!

Great service, no long line, and quick to get us our food!

Super friendly staff! We ordered chicken tenders and Alfy's Calzone and were very pleased, awesome salad bar to boot! The location is great, right off the water in Downtown Oak Harbor aaand the views from the second floor are terrific. They have a great game room where the only games you pay for are the claw games where you can get a prize. The free ones are classic game emulators from the 8 bit Nintendo, Super Nintendo, and PS1 (all of which I loved as a kid). We'll definitely be back!

Really great! The pizza is delicious and they have great deals.

Absolutely horrible pizza. Too thick crust. Fake greasy cheese. Uneven cut. Just a bad pizza. Pretty sure I could get a better frozen pizza than this. Would not go back.

Great service and pizza 👍🏻

Great little spot on the water. The food was great, the staff was friendly and took care of us. I love their salad bar! Only thing I could say needed work was the wings need to be alittle more crispy but that's it. It really is a great place. They also do take home n bake Pizza for half off regular price!

Their food is pretty good. Not the best pizza I've had, but it's the only sit down pizza in Oak Harbor. Good selection of beer and cider on tap. Excellent military discount.

Really good pizza, fun atmosphere, and half price pizza everyday from 11-2. Plus BOGO on mondays.

Great food. Great view. A touch pricey, but I say WORTH it.

Was craving some pizza, wings, and beer for dinner one night while visiting Oak Harbor. Found it all at Alfy’s. The service was good, the pizza was... OK, but stay away from the wings. Great tasting hot sauce on them but they were VERY fatty. I was only able to eat about half of them after pulling all the skin and fat off. Started to get grossed out. I got the traditional bone in. Perhaps the boneless would’ve been better??? If you’re looking for just pizza and a good selection of beers, I’d say give them a try. If your looking for wings, keep looking.

A very nice pizza restaurant with a warm, friendly and inviting feel. It's a perfect place for family gatherings or to enjoy alone. The food is really fresh and they have a wide variety of menu items. The staff is always helpful and cheery.

Great building. Great views. Great food and awesome salad bar. Game room for kids. Kinda pricey, but the food is awesome. Great place for groups and parties.

Really good pizza!

Awesome pizza and salad bar. You don't see those anymore. Fabulous prices too!

Order on the first floor & sit either on the first or second floor. Second floor has a lot of room & has a nice layout - great for big parties or private dates. Pizza & breadsticks are good quality & food is made pretty quickly. The wait staff are awesome too - very friendly & helpful.

Nice water view. Very good pizza, salad bar and decent selection of beers. Overall, good pizza place.

Always liked the view from this location. Plus pizza & all you can eat salad bar.

Good food. A little spendy. $25 buck for a LG 2 topping pizza. It was really good pizza though.

Fast service, good food, nice people.

Really good pizza and great salad bar

Good pizza! Seahawks game was going so pizza was half price. Good deal for locals

Great Pizza Place that were our family regularly eats or picks food up from

Good pizza, breathtaking views, decent beer selection...worst customer service ever. A dine in restaurant shouldn’t have the feel of the fast food atmosphere. Sadly as a prior server, that kills everything for me and will likely not go back.

Student, teacher discounts, friendly service (& fast) excellent pizza, great local beer selection on draft, game room, beautiful views... Worth a visit!

First time we've been there. Service was great as was the salad bar and the happy hour pizza. Filled us up and had some left overs for our trip home.

Alfy's Pizza in Oak Harbor was delish. The salad bar was generous. Lots of choices for pizza toppings! Clean restaurant with sweet staff. Good experience!

Got the Alfys special, and i must say the quality of the toppings and pizza itself very apparent. The prices are a bit more then I am used to paying for a typical pizza but it was well worth it. Loads of toppings, cheese and a very vibrant sauce with a slight kick. There is a small bar/ pub area on the ground level, and nice upper patio seating section which would be perfect for seeing a nice sunset sky in the harbor. Overall enjoyed the experience and will be back. Also worth noting they offer a nice military discount.

Many People may not agree with my view of this establishment... Though to be brutally honest, if I wanted greasy-soggy crust(which was burned AND soggy, how you manage that I've yet to understand) sauce from a can Pizza this where you want to go. Otherwise ANY of the other big name chains is 5🌟 compared to this place. Oh and their salad bar is from cans/containers as well. -.- a shameful waste of $$$ only gave it 1🌟 because it's required IT IS Undeserving of even that.

This is the best pizza on the island. Plus their deals are amazing. Half off between 11 and 2? Wow.

Great food and prices are nice around happy hour

Awesome family friendly environment and great food. So great, I even took a picture....whoops

Very yummy. Always enjoy it here.

Good pizza. Relaxing atmosphere. Great views of the water.

We needed a fast eat and came across good reviews. The place is huge, with two floors. The cashier was very friendly and greeted us immediately. We had the Alfy's special and it was excellent! Not a large selection of games for kids but they do have four free game consoles. I'll be going back in the day time so we can get a better look through their large ocean view windows.

Looks nice, pizza is not bad... It's good. Clean environment. TV screens with sports. Upstairs window seats make it nice. Arcade .... Terrible it really ruins the mood when you have a Scrappy arcade setup. Prices bit steep.

It’s a cute place, with a little arcade in the back. Nice upstairs and downstairs dining areas. The pizza was fantastic, and the salad bar is extensive and wonderful as well. Overall I loved this place!

Good food and good seating. Cust. service is good too

We decided to try Alfy's on our way up to the Deception Pass bridge. The place was nice and clean, had a beautiful water view with huge windows. The pizza was absolutely delicious!! It came out quick and had wonderful flavor and the crust had a great texture. They had a large salad bar and it looked like a big selection. The place was empty on Sunday when we walked in and packed when we left. The kids loved that they could play games in the arcade without paying, super cool for parents.I deducted one star because the gal at the counter was rude and I overheard her belittling another employee whom I assume she was in charge of. No need for behavior like that, life is hard enough!!